Alternative Pluripotent Stem cell Therapies Enhancement Act
18 July 2006
HON. RON PAUL
OF TEXAS
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Tuesday, July 18, 2006
2006 Ron Paul 57:1
Mr. PAUL. Mr. Speaker, the issue of government
funding of embryonic stem cell research
is one of the most divisive issues facing
the country. While I sympathize with those
who see embryonic stem cell research as providing
a path to a cure for the dreadful diseases
that have stricken so many Americans,
I strongly object to forcing those Americans
who believe embryonic stem cell research is
immoral to subsidize such research with their
tax dollars.
2006 Ron Paul 57:2
The main question that should concern Congress today is does the United States Government
have the constitutional authority to fund
any form of stem cell research. The clear answer
to that question is no. A proper constitutional
position would reject federal funding for
stem cell research, while allowing the individual
states and private citizens to decide
whether to permit, ban, or fund this research.
Therefore, I will vote to uphold President
Bushs expected veto of H.R. 810.
2006 Ron Paul 57:3
Unfortunately, many opponents of embryonic stem cell research are disregarding the
Constitution by supporting S. 2754, an acceptable
alternative that funds non-embryonic
stem cell research. While this approach is
much less objectionable than funding embryonic
stem cell research, it is still unconstitutional.
Therefore, I must also oppose S. 2754.
2006 Ron Paul 57:4
Federal funding of medical research guarantees the politicization of decisions about what
types of research for what diseases will be
funded. Thus, scarce resources will be allocated
according to who has the most effective
lobby rather than allocated on the basis of
need or even likely success. Federal funding
will also cause researchers to neglect potential
treatments and cures that do not qualify for
federal funds.
2006 Ron Paul 57:5
In order to promote private medical research, I have introduced the Cures Can Be
Found Act (H.R. 3444). H.R. 3444 promotes
medical research by providing a tax credit for
investments and donations to promote adult
and umbilical cord blood stem cell research
and providing a $2,000 tax credit to new parents
for the donation of umbilical cord blood
from which to extract stem cells. The Cures
Can Be Found Act will ensure greater resources
are devoted to this valuable research.
The tax credit for donations of umbilical cord
blood will ensure that medical science has a
continuous supply of stem cells. Thus, this bill
will help scientists discover new cures using
stem cells and, hopefully, make routine the
use of stem cells to treat formerly incurable
diseases.
2006 Ron Paul 57:6
H.R. 3444 will benefit companies like Prime Cell, which is making great progress in transforming
non-embryonic stem cells into any cell
type in the body. Prime Cell is already talking
to health care practitioners about putting its
findings to use to help cure diseases.
2006 Ron Paul 57:7
Companies like Prime Cell are continuing the great American tradition of private medical
research that is responsible for many medical
breakthroughs. For example, Jonas Salk, discoverer
of the polio vaccine, did not receive
one dollar from the federal government for his
efforts.
2006 Ron Paul 57:8
Mr. Speaker, there is no question that forcing taxpayers to subsidize embryonic stem cell
research violates basic constitutional principles.
However, S. 2754 also exceeds
Congresss constitutional authority and may
even retard effective adult stem cell research.
Therefore, I urge my colleagues to vote
against S. 2754 and vote to uphold President
Bushs veto of H.R. 810. Instead, I urge my
colleagues to support H.R. 3444, the Cures
Can Be Found Act.