Mr. SANDERS. Mr. Chairman, I yield
1 1/2 minutes to the gentleman from
Texas (Mr. PAUL).
(Mr. PAUL asked and was given permission
to revise and extend his remarks.)
2004 Ron Paul 51:1
Mr. PAUL. Mr. Chairman, I think it would be proper to rename this amendment
and call it the partial restoration
of the fourth amendment, and
that is our attempt here. We are doing
exactly what the gentleman early on
suggested: this is oversight; this is our
responsibility. This is the proper place
to have the debate. It was the Congress
that created the PATRIOT Act; it is
the responsibility of the Congress to do
something about it if it was a mistake.
And it, indeed, was a mistake.
2004 Ron Paul 51:2
I would like to think that the American people are with us entirely, and I
know a large number already are with
us on trying to straighten up some of
the mess caused by the Patriot Act,
but I would like to say that there is
one basic principle that we should approach
this with, something I approach
all legislation with, and that is the
principle of a free society is that we
never have to sacrifice liberty in order
to preserve it.
2004 Ron Paul 51:3
The whole notion that the purpose of providing freedom and liberty to this
country is that we have to give up
some, I do not believe is necessary. It
is never necessary to give up freedom
to preserve freedom. I do think we
made some serious mistakes. We made
a mistake in passing the PATRIOT Act
under conditions of an emergency and
under the conditions of post-9/11. We
did not do a very good job at Tora
Bora. We failed to find the individuals
responsible for 9/11 and we have not
concentrated on the people who committed
this crime. Instead, we have decided
to invade and occupy a foreign
country rather than protecting and
providing security here, at home providing
freedom for our people and more
security for this country.