2003 Ron Paul 69:1
Mr. PAUL. Mr. Speaker: I will reluctantly vote in favor of this legislation, partly because
it is simply a sense of Congress resolution.
But I am concerned about this bill and the others
like it we face with regularity on the floor
of Congress. We all condemn violence against
innocents, whether it is motivated by hatred,
prejudice, greed, jealousy, or whatever else.
But that is not what this legislation is really
about. It is about the Congress of the United
States presuming to know — and to legislate
on — the affairs of European countries. First,
this is the United States Congress. We have
no Constitutional authority to pass legislation
affecting foreign countries. Second, when we
get involved in matters such as this we usually
get it wrong. H. Con. Res. 45 is an example
of us getting it wrong on both fronts.
2003 Ron Paul 69:2
This legislation refers to the rise of anti- Semitism in Europe as if it is a purely homegrown
phenomenon, as if native residents of
European countries are suddenly committing
violent crimes against Jews. But I think we are
only getting part of the story here. What is absent
from the legislation is mention of the wellreported
fact that much of the anti-Jewish violence
in Europe is perpetrated by recent immigrants
from Muslim countries of the Middle
East and Africa. Reporting on a firebombing of
a Synagogue in Marseille, France, for example,
the New York Times quotes the longtime
president of that regions Jewish Council,
Charles Haddad, as saying, This is not anti-
Semitic violence; its the Middle East conflict
thats playing out here.
2003 Ron Paul 69:3
Therefore, part of the problem in many European countries is the massive immigration
from predominantly Muslim countries, where
new residents bring their hatreds and prejudices
with them. Those European politicians
who recognize this growing problem — there
are now 600,000 Jews in France and five million
Muslims — are denounced as racist and
worse. While I do not oppose immigration, it
must be admitted that massive immigration
from vastly different cultures brings a myriad
of potential problems and conflicts. These are
complicated issues for we in Congress to deal
with here in the United States. Yes, prejudice
and hatred are evil and must be opposed, but
it is absurd for us to try to solve these problems
in countries overseas.