Condemning The Selection Of Libya To Chair The United Nations Commission On Human Rights
11 February 2003
SPEECH OF
HON. RON PAUL
OF TEXAS
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Tuesday, February 11, 2003
2003 Ron Paul 19:1
Mr. PAUL. Mr. Speaker, I must reluctantly vote against this measure. We can all agree
that Libya is a ridiculous choice to head a
human rights commission in any civilized organization.
The State Department has long listed
Libya on its list of states sponsoring terrorism.
Libya has shown over the years that it has no
respect whatsoever for human rights, when it
comes to its dealings with the rest of the world
or even its own citizens. Additionally, this election
just underscores what I have been saying
for years about the United Nations: it is an organization
that undermines American sovereignty
and consistently works against U.S.
interests.
2003 Ron Paul 19:2
The problem with this legislation, however, is that it pretends to be something it is not. It
pretends to be simply a condemnation of the
elevation of Libya to head the UN Commission
on Human Rights. Were that the case I would
have voted in favor of the measure.
2003 Ron Paul 19:3
But unfortunately the legislation ventures off course from there. The legislation calls on the
president to demand that sanctions against
Libya be initiated anew, after they had already
been suspended. I do not believe that sanctions
have ever hurt a dictator or repressive
regime. On the contrary, sanctions against an
authoritarian regime only give the leaders a
scapegoat for the sufferings of their people —
while the leadership itself manages to avoid
any hardship. Sanctions do not lead to the defeat
of these kinds of regimes, but actually
strengthen them.
2003 Ron Paul 19:4
Cuba is an excellent example: the United States has maintained sanctions against that
nation for four decades, but its dictator is
stronger than ever. The best way to break the
hold of dictatorship on a country is to engage
and trade with that country. Trade with a repressive
regime brings in goods and ideas
that undermine the hold of the ruling elites on
power. It breaks the monopolization on economic
activity that characterizes a closed society
and economic system. It weakens dictatorships
and it enriches the population.
2003 Ron Paul 19:5
Mr. Speaker, I join my fellow members in condemning Libyas election to chair the UN
Human Rights Committee. I do not support
sanctions, be they against Libya or any other
country.