HON. RON PAUL OF TEXAS
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
February 5, 2003
Education Improvement Tax Cut Act
2003 Ron Paul 16:1
Mr. PAUL. Mr. Speaker, I rise to introduce the Education Improvement Tax
Cut Act.
This act, a companion to my Family Education Freedom Act, takes a
further step
toward returning control over education resources to private citizens
by
providing a $3,000 tax credit for donations to scholarship funds to
enable
low-income children to attend private schools. It also encourages
private
citizens to devote more of their resources to helping public schools,
by
providing a $3,000 tax credit for cash or in-kind donations to public
schools to
support academic or extra curricular programs.
2003 Ron Paul 16:2
I need not remind my colleagues that education is one of the top
priorities of the
American people. After all, many members of Congress have proposed
education
reforms and a great deal of time is spent debating these proposals.
However,
most of these proposals either expand federal control over education or
engage
in the pseudo-federalism of block
grants. Many proposals that claim to increase local control over
education
actually extend federal power by holding
schools accountable to federal bureaucrats and politicians. Of
course,
schools should be held accountable for their results, but they should
be held
accountable to parents and school boards not to federal officials.
Therefore, I
propose we move in a different direction and embrace true federalism by
returning control over the education dollar to the American people.
2003 Ron Paul 16:3
One of the major problems with centralized control over education funding
is that
spending priorities set by Washington-based Representatives, staffers,
and
bureaucrats do not necessarily match the needs of individual
communities. In fact, it would be a miracle if spending
priorities
determined by the wishes of certain politically powerful representatives
or the theories of Education Department functionaries match the
priorities of
every community in a country as large and diverse as America. Block
grants do
not solve this problem as they simply allow states and localities
to choose the means to reach federally-determined ends.
2003 Ron Paul 16:4
Returning control over the education dollar for tax credits for parents and for
other
concerned citizens returns control over
both the means and ends of education policy to local communities.
People in one
community may use this credit to purchase computers, while children in
another
community may, at last, have access to a quality music program because
of
community leaders who took advantage of the tax credit contained in
this bill.
2003 Ron Paul 16:5
Children in some communities may benefit most from the opportunity to attend
private,
parochial, or other religious schools.
One of the most encouraging trends in education has been the
establishment of
private scholarship programs. These
scholarship funds use voluntary contributions to open the doors of
quality
private schools to low-income children. By providing a tax credit for
donations
to these programs, Congress can widen the educational opportunities and
increase the quality of education for all children. Furthermore,
privately-funded scholarships raise none of the concerns of state
entanglement
raised by publicly-funded vouchers.
2003 Ron Paul 16:6
There is no doubt that Americans will always spend generously on education,
the
question is who should control the education dollar- politicians and
bureaucrats
or the American people? Mr. Speaker, I urge my colleagues to join
me in
placing control of education back in the hands of citizens and local
communities
by sponsoring the Education Improvement
Tax Cut Act.