HON. RON PAUL OF TEXAS
BEFORE THE U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
December 8, 2003
Whose Peace?
2003 Ron Paul 123:1
Much has been written lately about several attempts to
craft an alternative peace plan in the decades-old Israeli-Palestinian
dispute.
The best known of these recent plans - the “Geneva Initiative” -was
conceived and written by representatives of both sides of the conflict,
but
without the involvement of governments or politicians. As such, it is a
fresh
approach that should provide a lesson to those who continue to believe
that
peace is something that can only be crafted by government officials, or
bribed
and bullied by the “international community”.
2003 Ron Paul 123:2
We do know this: after decades of conflict and tens of
billions of US taxpayer dollars spent, US government involvement in the
Israeli-Palestinian peace process has led nowhere. The latest US
government-initiated plan for peace, the “road map,” appears to be a
map to
nowhere. This does not surprise me much. With a seemingly endless
amount of
money to bribe the leaders of the two opposing sides to remain engaged
in the
process, is it any wonder why the two parties never arrive at peace?
2003 Ron Paul 123:3
But people on both sides are becoming more and more
frustrated with the endless impasse and endless government and
bureaucrat-written peace agreements that go nowhere.
2003 Ron Paul 123:4
That is why plans like this should be of such interest.
Initially conceived by an obscure Swiss professor, the project was
joined by
former Israeli Justice Minister Yossi Beilin, former Palestinian
Authority
Information Minister Yasser Abed Rabbo, and by other prominent
individuals like
former president Jimmy Carter. The negotiations led to the creation of
a 50 page
detailed accord.
2003 Ron Paul 123:5
I do not know whether the product is perfect. I have not
studied the minute details of the proposal. But what I do know is that
politicians, governments, and special interests promote war at the
expense of
those who have to fight them. Wars end when the victims finally demand
peace.
And that is what we are beginning to see. According to one recent
survey, a
majority among both the Israeli and Palestinian population support this
new
initiative. That is encouraging.
2003 Ron Paul 123:6
To his credit, President Bush has demonstrated an open mind
toward this alternative approach. He declared the Geneva Initiative
“productive,” and added that the United States “appreciates people
discussing peace.” Secretary of State Colin Powell echoed the president
when
he resisted hard-line pressure to ignore the proposed accord, stating,
“I have
an obligation to listen to individuals who have interesting ideas.”
This is
also encouraging.
2003 Ron Paul 123:7
Predictably, though, this new approach is not as welcomed
by those-- governments, politicians, and special interests-- who have a
stake in
dragging out the process indefinitely. Palestinian Authority President
Yasser
Arafat has been lukewarm at best. Extremist Arab organizations that
have a
special interest in continuing the violence have also rejected the
Geneva
Initiative. Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has rejected the
Initiative out
of hand. Said Mr. Sharon: “Geneva is an attempt to do something only a
government can do.”
2003 Ron Paul 123:8
But the point is that governments have little incentive to
finally end conflicts such as these. The United States is in places
like Kosovo
and Bosnia indefinitely in the name of “peace-keeping” and “peace
processes”. The same will be true of our involvement in Afghanistan and
Iraq.
It is not until foreign involvement ceases — that means our
continued
meddling in the Middle East — and the people involved demand peace that
real
working solutions begin to emerge. The Geneva Initiative is therefore a
positive
step toward peace in the Middle East. Let us step back and get out of
the way!