HON. RON PAUL OF TEXAS
BEFORE THE US HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
October 6, 2004
No Mandatory Mental Health Screening for Kids
Mr. Speaker, I rise to introduce the Let Parents Raise Their Kids Act. This bill forbids federal funds from being used for any universal or mandatory mental-health screening of students without the express, written, voluntary, informed consent of their parents or legal guardians. This bill protects the fundamental right of parents to direct and control the upbringing and education of their children.
The
New Freedom Commission on Mental Health has recommended that the federal
government adopt a comprehensive system of mental-health screening for all
Americans.
The
commission recommends the government implement universal or mandatory mental-
health screening in public schools as a prelude to expanding it to the general
public. However, neither the commission’s report nor any related mental-health
screening proposal requires parental consent before a child is subjected to such
screening. Federally funded universal or mandatory mental-health screening in
schools without parental consent could lead to labeling more children as
“ADD” or “hyperactive,” and thus force more children to take
psychotropic drugs like Ritalin against their parents’ wishes.
Already,
too many children are suffering from being prescribed psychotropic drugs for
nothing more than children’s typical rambunctious behavior. According to the
Journal of the American Medical Association, there was a 300-percent increase in
psychotropic drug use in two to four-year old children from 1991 to 1995!
Many
children have suffered harmful side effects from using psychotropic drugs. Some
of the possible side effects include mania, violence, dependence, and weight
gain. Yet parents already are being threatened with child abuse charges if they
resist efforts to drug their children. Imagine how much easier it will be to
drug children against their parents’ wishes if a federal mental-health
screener makes the recommendation.
Universal or mandatory mental-health screening could also provide a justification for stigmatizing children from families that support traditional values. Even the authors of mental-health diagnosis manuals admit that mental-health diagnoses are subjective and based on social constructions. Therefore, it is all too easy for a psychiatrist to label a person’s disagreement with the psychiatrist’s political beliefs a mental disorder. For example, a federally funded school violence prevention program lists “intolerance” as a mental problem that may lead to school violence. Because “intolerance” is often a code word for believing in traditional values, children who share their parents’ values could be labeled as having mental problems and a risk of causing violence. If the mandatory mental-health screening program applies to adults, everyone who believes in traditional values could have his or her beliefs stigmatized as a sign of a mental disorder. Taxpayer dollars should not support programs that may label those who adhere to traditional values as having a “mental disorder.”
Mr. Speaker, universal or mandatory mental-health screening threatens to undermine parents’ right to raise their children as the parents see fit. Forced mental-health screening could also endanger the health of children by leading to more children being improperly placed on psychotropic drugs, such as Ritalin, or stigmatized as “mentally ill” or a risk of causing violence because they adhere to traditional values. Congress has a responsibility to the nation’s parents and children to stop this from happening. I, therefore, urge my colleagues to cosponsor the Let Raise Their Kids Act.