Ron Paul Quotes.com
Home Page Contents Congressional Record
21 October 1999
1999 Ron Paul 108:1
Mr. PAUL. Mr. Chairman, Congress is once again preparing to exceed its constitutional limits as well as ignore the true lesson of the last thirty years of education failure by reauthorizing Title I of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (SEA). Like most federal programs, Title I was launched with the best of intentions, however, good intentions are no excuse for Congress to exceed its constitutional limitations by depriving parents, local communities and states of their rightful authority over education. The tenth amendment does not contain an exception for good intentions!
1999 Ron Paul 108:2
The Congress that created Title I promised the American public that, in exchange for giving up control over their schools and submitting to increased levels of taxation,
1999 Ron Paul 108:3
Supporters of a constitutional education policy should be heartened that Congress has finally recognized that simply throwing federal taxpayer money at local schools will not improve education. However, too many in Congress continue to cling to the belief that the right federal program conceived by enlightened members and staffers will lead to educational nirvana. In fact, a cursory review of this legislation reveals at least five new mandates imposed on the states by this bill; this bill also increases federal expenditures by $27.7 billion over the next five years — yet the drafters of this legislation somehow manage to claim with a straight face that this bill promotes local control!
1999 Ron Paul 108:4
One mandate requires states to give priority to
1999 Ron Paul 108:5
Another mandate requires teacher aides to be fully qualified if the aides are to be involved in instructing students. Again, while this may appear to be simply a matter of following sound practice, the cost of hiring qualified teaching assistants will add a great burden to many small and rural school districts. Many of these districts may have to go without teachers aides, placing another burden on our already overworked public school teachers.
1999 Ron Paul 108:6
Some may claim that this bill does not contain mandates as no state must accept federal funds. However, since obeying federal educrats is the only way states and localities can retrieve any of the education funds unjustly taken from their citizens by oppressive taxation, it is the rare state that will not submit to federal specifications.
1999 Ron Paul 108:7
One of the mantras of those who promote marginal reforms of federal education programs is the need to hold schools accountable for their use of federal funds. This is the justification for requiring Title I schools to produce report cards listing various indicators of school performance. Of course, no one would argue against holding schools should be accountable, but accountable to whom? The Federal Government? Simply requiring schools to provide information about the schools, without giving parents the opportunity to directly control their childs education does not hold schools accountable to parents. As long as education dollars remain in the hands of bureaucrats not parents, schools will remain accountable to bureaucrats instead of parents.
1999 Ron Paul 108:8
Furthermore, maximum decentralization is the key to increasing education quality. This is because decentralized systems are controlled by those who know the unique needs of an individual child, whereas centralized systems are controlled by bureaucrats who impose a one-size fits all model. The model favored by bureaucrats can never meet the special needs of individual children in the local community because the bureaucrats have no way of knowing those particular needs. Small wonder that students in states with decentralized education score 10 percentage points higher on the NAEP tests in math and reading than students in states with centralized education.
1999 Ron Paul 108:9
Fortunately there is an alternative educational policy to the one before us today that respects the Constitution and improves education by restoring true accountability to Americas education system. Returning real control to the American people by returning direct control of the education dollars to Americas parents and concerned citizens is the only proper solution. This is precisely why I have introduced the Family Education Freedom Act (HR 935). The Family Education Freedom Act provides parents with a $3,000 per child tax credit for the
1999 Ron Paul 108:10
By placing control of education funding directly into the hands of parents and concerned citizens, my bills restore true accountability to education. When parents control education funding, schools must respond to the parents desire for a quality education, otherwise the parent will seek other educational options for their child.
1999 Ron Paul 108:11
Instead of fighting over what type of federal intervention is best for education, Congress should honor their constitutional oath and give complete control over Americas educational system to the states and people. Therefore, Congress should reject this legislation and instead work to restore true accountability to Americas parents by defunding the education bureaucracy and returning control of the education dollar to Americas parents.
1999 Ron Paul 108:1 The tenth amendment probably should be capitalized: The Tenth Amendment.
1999 Ron Paul 108:2 federally-empowered probably should be unhyphenated: federally empowered.
1999 Ron Paul 108:4 K–6 probably should have a hyphen and not a dash: K-6.
1999 Ron Paul 108:7 Of course, no one would argue against holding schools should be accountable probably should be Of course, no one would argue against holding schools accountable.
1999 Ron Paul 108:8 “one-size fits all” probably should be either the unhyphenated “one size fits all” or one-size-fits-all without quotation marks.